Top Underrated TV Shows to Binge Right Now on Netflix and Prime
Let’s be honest—some of the best TV shows don’t make it to the front page. They hide in the shadows like introverts at a party, waiting to be discovered. If you’ve been endlessly scrolling through Netflix or Prime Video wondering, “What the heck should I watch next?”—you’re in the right place.
We're diving headfirst into the pool of underrated Netflix series and hidden gems on Prime Video that deserve your eyeballs immediately. Ready to find your next obsession?
Why These Underrated TV Shows Deserve Your Attention
Streaming platforms are flooded with new content every week. But let’s face it—algorithm-based recommendations can be as off as pineapple on pizza (no offense, pineapple lovers). That’s where this guide steps in—to bring you the top underrated streaming shows that somehow slipped through the cracks.
1. Dark (Netflix)
Genre: Sci-Fi, Mystery, Thriller
Imagine Stranger Things and Inception had a German baby. That’s Dark. A time-traveling mind-bender wrapped in family drama and quantum physics. It’s one of the most underrated Netflix series ever made, and if you're a fan of thinking way too hard while watching TV, this is your jam.
2. Patriot (Prime Video)
Genre: Dark Comedy, Spy Thriller
With its quirky storytelling and dry wit, Patriot is like Wes Anderson directed a spy show. It’s a satirical take on espionage with a melancholic edge. Hidden in plain sight, it’s one of the best hidden gems on Prime Video for 2025 binge sessions.
3. Giri/Haji (Netflix)
Genre: Crime, Drama, Thriller
A Japanese detective travels to London to find his missing brother, and what follows is a poetic fusion of crime and honor. It’s stylized, bold, and emotionally gripping—easily one of the top underrated Netflix series you need to watch.
4. Undone (Prime Video)
Genre: Animation, Sci-Fi, Drama
This rotoscope-animated gem explores time travel, mental health, and trauma in a way that’s both trippy and touching. Undone is a visual poem, and yes, it’s criminally under-watched. Don't sleep on this underrated TV show for 2025.
5. Rectify (Netflix)4>
Genre: Drama
Slow-burn? Yes. Boring? Heck no. Rectify explores life after death row with quiet power and poetic realism. If you want a show that haunts your soul—in the best way—start binging this beautiful under-the-radar Netflix series tonight.
6. The Wilds (Prime Video)
Genre: Drama, Thriller
Think Lost but with teenage girls and a conspiracy that thickens faster than cold honey. It's not just another teen drama—it’s layered, smart, and severely underrated. One of the best hidden gems on Prime Video for 2025.
7. Mindhunter (Netflix)
Genre: Crime, Thriller
If you like your thrillers cold and calculated, Mindhunter is your next addiction. Based on the real-life birth of criminal profiling, this show crawls under your skin. It’s one of those binge-worthy Netflix shows you’ll mourn once it's over.
8. ZeroZeroZero (Prime Video)
Genre: Crime, Thriller
This one’s a rollercoaster through the global cocaine trade—like Narcos but grittier and more global. With three intertwining storylines, it’s raw, cinematic, and deserves way more hype. One of the top underrated streaming content of the year.
9. Russian Doll (Netflix)
Genre: Comedy, Sci-Fi, Drama
Death never looked so stylish. Natasha Lyonne keeps dying—and reliving the same night—in this witty, deeply philosophical show. It’s a hilarious meditation on trauma, fate, and free will. Definitely one of the most underrated Netflix series out there.
10. Fortitude (Prime Video)
Genre: Mystery, Horror, Thriller
Set in a chilling Arctic town with even chillier secrets, Fortitude blends murder mystery with sci-fi horror. It’s eerie, atmospheric, and filled with “wait, what just happened?” moments. Perfect for late-night streaming recommendations.
11. Maniac (Netflix)
Genre: Sci-Fi, Drama, Comedy
Jonah Hill and Emma Stone in a pharmaceutical test gone haywire? Yes, please. Maniac is an experimental dive into mental illness and simulated realities. It’s odd in the best way—just like your favorite dream you can’t quite explain.
12. Forever (Prime Video)
Genre: Comedy, Drama
What happens after "happily ever after"? This series explores marriage and monotony in the afterlife—literally. With Maya Rudolph and Fred Armisen, it’s subtly brilliant and one of those underrated TV shows to binge right now if you want something totally different.
13. The OA (Netflix)
Genre: Sci-Fi, Drama, Mystery
The OA is part performance art, part spiritual awakening, part sci-fi riddle. It’s bold, bizarre, and not for everyone—which makes it all the more special for those who get it. Seriously, it’s one of the best shows you’re missing on Netflix.
14. Hap and Leonard (Prime Video)
Genre: Crime, Dark Comedy
A Southern-fried noir with a killer duo at the center, Hap and Leonard blends pulp fiction, friendship, and gritty crime stories. It’s rough around the edges—in the best way—and one of the top underrated streaming shows you’ve likely never heard of.
15. Safe (Netflix)
Genre: Thriller, Mystery
From the mind of Harlan Coben, this mystery series packs secrets, lies, and suburban suspense into a neat, binge-worthy package. It’s got twists, drama, and a plot that pulls you in like quicksand. Perfect for fans of fast-paced whodunits.
Final Thoughts: Your Next Favorite Show is Just a Click Away
Not every masterpiece gets a billboard. Sometimes, the best TV shows are the ones no one told you about. These series recommendations on Netflix and Prime are more than just good—they’re unforgettable. So grab your remote, skip the scroll, and dive into these top underrated streaming shows right now.
FAQs
What are some underrated Netflix series worth watching in 2025?
Shows like Dark, Mindhunter, The OA, and Russian Doll are top underrated Netflix series you need to watch this year.
Which hidden gems on Prime Video are best for binge-watching?
Patriot, Undone, ZeroZeroZero, and Forever are fantastic hidden gems on Prime Video for 2025.
Are there any binge-worthy Netflix shows that are under the radar?
Absolutely. Giri/Haji, Rectify, and Maniac are all binge-worthy Netflix shows that haven’t gotten the love they deserve.
What makes a TV show "underrated"?
It usually means the show didn’t receive mainstream attention or awards but still delivers amazing storytelling, acting, and production value.
Where can I find more series recommendations for Netflix and Prime?
Besides platform recommendations, curated lists like this one are great ways to discover top underrated streaming content of the year.